Father's Day Tray (S)
Planning to order more than 5 trays as a gift? Sign up for a call wit hour team and we can process the details for you.
In order to avoid product damage and reduced quality, we do not ship cheese event plates or cheese trays at this time.
Please check out our collections and Cheese Club that are designed to survive the rigors of shipping.
Can I select my own cheeses? Our cheese trays are thoughtfully curated and come as preset selections—no need to make tough decisions! Each tray features a variety of styles (like soft, firm, and blue) and milk types (like goat, cow, sheep) to offer something for everyone, from cheese novices to full-blown turophiles. Looking for a completely custom selection? Swing by our Retail Shop, and one of our friendly cheesemongers will help you pick the perfect cheeses to build your own tray at home.
What if I don’t like a certain type of cheese? While we don’t offer full customization, we’re happy to honor common requests like: “No blue cheese,” “No soft cheeses,” or “Pasteurized-only cheeses.” Just leave us a note at checkout and we’ll do our best to accommodate.
What are the pairings offered? We try to showcase the 5 tastes: sweet, salty, bitter, sour, and umami - as a compliment to the cheese selection. While it can vary, we generally include a selection of fresh and dried fruits, pickled vegetables and/or olives, and Quicos (addictive Spanish corn nuts).
Not sure what cheese tray size to get? A good rule of thumb is 1 ounce of each cheese per person for a dinner portion, or 2-3 ounces total for light grazing.
What if we have allergies? Please specify any allergies when ordering. We do build our cheese trays in our facilities, where marcona almonds and bread are present. Additionally, we use latex or vinyl gloves when plating food.
Does it come with crackers or bread? No, but you can add boxes of crackers of a plated Cracker Tray.
What if I eat gluten-free? Good news! There is no gluten on our cheese plates. You can add on GF crackers to your purchase and our Cracker Tray is gluten-free.
Is the tray compostable? Our Cheese Boards are made from wood and lined with food-grade wax paper. We tried a compostable board, but it fell apart on too many folks. So while we continue to look for the next best thing, we’re using our tried and true sturdy boards (that have now become popular nationwide - yes, we’ll take some credit for being originals!). Due to food service rules and health department standards, we cannot reuse cheese trays. However, you can! We often flip them over, put wax paper down, and serve right on them from home.
Option 1: We can move your scheduled pickup/delivery to a future date.
Option 2: Cancellations with 24 hours advance notice will be refunded to the credit card used to purchase.
Option 3: Cancellation that occur on the day of pickup or delivery will be refunded via store credit / gift card.
Please email hello@antonellischeese.com with order details.
For your convenience and to avoid wait times, online orders should be picked up at your selected time and location. For Hyde Park, visit our pickup window located in the alley behind Uncle Nicky's. For South Lamar please enter through the front door.
Hyde Park - View map here
Visit our Hyde Park Store or South Lamar Tasting Room to place an order for a cheese tray and have it ready within 20 minutes.
- Hyde Park - 7 days a week between 11am-6pm.
- South Lamar - Tue-Sat 11am-4pm.
This service is not available on Thanksgiving Eve, two days leading up to Christmas and New Years Eve. In addition it may not be available on other busy holidays so please call in advance to confrim.